Friday, 9 March 2012

NASA and the Sikh's Sri Guru Granth Sahib

A Blog Post by Bayani Mills (@bayanimills)

In June 2007 a story began to circulate that NASA was testing various Holy Scriptures for their scientific integrity, and that NASA was stunned by a specific book about its "answers" about their questions about the Universe.

I first heard of this from a Sikh I work with, he explained to me that 
that NASA “consults” the SGGS for answers to their questions about the cosmos, and that the SGGS had divine knowledge not known to man at the time, referencing the heliocentric model as a specific example, he assured me that it was a Sikh Guru who first suggested the Earth was not the center of the solar system – no one else.

When questioned, he was adamant that the story was true, declaring that his source was a news website, though despite repeated attempts, he never came through with a link to it.  So, I started to have a look around for the source - And found it:

Since the initial post, the story has been recycled in a number of different ways with mixed reactions by Sikhs; some are rightly skeptical, others apathetic, and some quite credulous about the whole matter.

In 2008 the instigator of the myth, Manpreet Singh confirmed he wrote the article without evidence to support his story -:

Thanks Manvir I had written an article on NASA taking Guru Granth Sahib help..last year..and many people asked me to back it up with some proof..Today you have given it to me..” -

Manpreet was referring to audio on where, according to the website, the host, Bhai Bhagwan Singh is said to be recounting a meeting with Banarsi Lal Chawla. Banarsi Lal’s daughter was Kalpana Chawla, a space shuttle mission specialist and was the first Panjabi to travel into space. She died on the 1st of February 2003 with the six other crew members in the Space Shuttle Columbia disaster.

Bhai Bhagwan Singh recounts Banarsi Lal telling him that his daughter performed daily prayers in the morning, was a vegetarian, recited Japji Sahib whilst she worked, and recited Japji Sahib while in space.

The host tells the story of how Banarsi Lal had an opportunity to visit the NASA centre at San Jose and that it was during his visit there he was shown a volume of an English translation of the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, kept at the NASA library. It was also while there, Banarsi was told “when scientists get tired of searching and searching the universe, when they seek inspiration and need to uplift their souls they turn to read the translations of Guru Nanak’s poetry and divine-songs which describe the awe and wonder of the Universe.”

Despite the claims made by Bhai Bhagwan Singh about Banarsi Lal and Kalpana, I came across a post by JeanPierre Harrison, Kalpana’s husband, where he stated the following at this forum.

It is a mystery - as well as dishonest - how people dream up this nonsense. Kalpana was antagonistic towards and had absolutely no interest in religion. She is the last person one would ever find studying any religious text. It is also quote obvious that researchers at NASA Ames do not search Guru Granth Sahib for "inspiration". NASA Ames is a scientific institution, not a wasteland of superstition.”

I got in contact with Jean Pierre to verify that it was him that made the statement. He confirmed that it was, explicitly expressing his anger that people would use Kalpana’s name to peddle their superstitions.

Ultimately, the fact is NASA does have a massive collection of books in their numerous libraries; while I was not able to verify that ANY religious book formed part of these libraries, it certainly would not surprise me - It would not also surprise me that men of science would enjoy a bit of poetry about the universe; but what would be surprising is if NASA was getting answers about the universe from a 500 year old text, rather than the instruments they spent millions putting in to space.

When NASA scientists want to know specific answers about the cosmos, they look up to the skies – they don’t read religious books.

Bayani Mills is an amateur skeptic with an interest in science and technology. More of his promotion of critical thinking and skeptical activism can be found at his website.


Charanjit Singh said...

Sounds like a very plausible account of how the story spread.
Leaving everything aside, the SGGS contains references to the universe which just mimic the popular lore prevalent about it at that time. Among other things, akasa (sky), patala (nether world) tre lok (three worlds) are mentioned in the same breath as the description of the Universe.

Rocks said...

Superb article. Just loved reading it. Check US open results

Anonymous said...

Though the author has tried to add more flavor to the original story and , again, without any evidence of his source, has created another story around the stories that are already around. such an author has very limited and dismal knowledge of Sri Guru Granth sahib Ji.. referring it to a '500 year old text' just shows his narrow mindedness and before referring to any religion or religious text or quote, one should learn the history behind it, which the author definitely has no clue about. Satinder Kaur

teachers day sms said...

Nice chunk of information. Will love to read it more and more time.

search engine submission sites list said...

Will share it across social media platforms as I found this very helpful.

Anonymous said...

The author of this so called skeptic blog seems to have quite the ignorance and narrowmindedness. They should read about the Guru Granth Sahib Ji and/or other religious texts before dismissing it aside and making preconceived notions.

Anonymous said...

Some racist dude who thinks Sikhism is superstitious in an attempt to defend Hinduism. The SGGS is beyond any religious text. I have read the major scriptures and only Sikhism is close to the truth.

Anonymous said...

To the SKEPTIC that wrote this.
I understand wholly that NASA would not turn to Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji for answers to the universe.
That said, do not disrespect our most sublime Guru the way you have done. You are supposed to be a learned person, but the bile that spills from your mouth is of an idiot. Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji wrote 500 years ago that there are thousands of other worlds with life on them, and what is being discovered now, worlds that can support life. If people actually listened to our Guru they could learn a lot more, but everyone has their own path.
I just ask you to keep your bile to yourself, or better still, research both sides of the story before you disrespect our faith and most of all our most loving Guru.